Kawboy wrote: lifeisaroad.com/stories/2004/10/27/theDarkSide.html - Another great article Hillsy, Thanks for sharing. It obviously contravenes all normal thinking BUT this guy has acted very much like a test pilot and discusses all aspects from mounting installing to mileage expected and everything in between, Can't argue with his findings. My first thought when I got to the middle of his report was that he probably doesn't ride hard, spending more time upright than down in the twisties, but apparently he does ride hard. Now he doesn't suggest that the car tires he's tested are better than the motorcycle tires in handling and it looks like the advantage is the tire wear with little to no major issues with handling. He does make a note that he would not put the car tire on the front of his bike. Personally, I get a little nervous when I start running different tread patterns, especially when I'm riding on wet roads. I'm not sure that I would like to be a test pilot on a 700 lb. bike and go and throw it throuth the twistis and take the chance of grinding off my leg in a grinding crash with the bike on top of me. But my days of riding hard are over.
He did note that the rim on the Valyrie is not that dissimilar from a car rim. From the drawings provided in the previous post, the rim design big difference appears to be whewre the bead lock sits in relationship to the bead flange and on the motorcycle rim, the bead lock is closer to the flange and holds the car tire bead in a position that doesn't allow the bead to seat properly. Maybe the Valkyrie bead lock is more like the car rims? and maybe the tire bead deforms enough to accomodate the difference in the rim. It would be very difficult to determine just exactly what's happening with this combination.
We digress here. Paul is asking what wheel (tire /rim) to put on his sidecar. I would think the only concern would be in supporting the weight and not necessarily any concerns regarding handling. It would be nice to hear from Trikebldr here. He's the Master of all things 3 wheeled.
Sorry to keep it on the darkside path, but the bit about the "bead not seating properly" with the car tyre on the bike rim, well that's not true. The cutaway pic he shows in the article doesn't take into account that the bead still goes over lip and comes back down onto the rim.
There is no "gap" between the bead and the rim like in this diagram. It seals hard. In fact, m/c rims are slightly larger in diameter than a corresponding car rim so the car tyre is quite difficult to seat on the m/c rim. Correspondingly, it's harder to get off.
As for the performance / cornering aspect it's naturally a different feel than an m/c tyre. But if you use a car tyre on a heavy bike with limited lean angles it can perform very well. You wouldn't expect to put one on a 180kg sportsbike and expect to scrape pegs or otherwise out-perform a m/c tyre.