I've tried the wood chisel as well.The problem I had with it is it's unforgiving. I said 'exacto' but I know there are many types and shapes of it. What worked best for me was a long blade used for a cutter knife. They are sold in a package of 10 at any dollar store. They are flexible, and in circular motions easy to work through the gasket. Thin, flexible and not heavy, they want cause damage like a chisel would if catching a surface. Applying some pressure they arch and offer some room for error and smoothness. With chisel I ended up digging into the surface. With chisel I had to apply much more pressure while trying to remove the gasket in straight line digging into it - because of the edge profile. With the blade it was more like shaving it off in circular motion - it's thin and it just cut through. I found chisel be good to remove hardened liquid gasket overflown around the edges. But you have to use it with real care, anticipating hitting the surface when the gasket gets loose.